Clue Mystery Party
party prep for Across the Clueniverse
Since I was unable to have a Mardi Gras party this year because I was on my way back from the work cruise, I decided to have a party for which I’ve had a glimmer of an idea for years – Clue! Yes, the Miss Scarlett, Colonel Mustard, Mrs. Peacock board game we all know & love! Not long after I graduated college & had my own place, my mom gave me a pair of large silverplate candlesticks, and I said “These look like the one from Clue!” A few years ago when Melanie was cleaning her closet, she gave me a floor-length red velvet dress and I said “This would be the perfect Miss Scarlett dress!” The idea was percolating in the back of my head along with tons of other ideas, but with my Potter parties and already too many other theme parties each year, I had no idea when I could fit in a Clue party, so didn’t give it much thought. Then last year I had three people on separate occasions and completely independently say to me “You know what you should do? A Clue party!” When I first heard of the schedule for the work cruise conflicting with my Mardi Gras plans, I decided to skip Mardi Gras and try a Clue party later in the spring.
I have seen the Clue movie again recently thanks to 
We might also watch the Clue movie if the group feels so inclined.
Party prep was started awhile ago of course, but since I’m not intending this to be as elaborate as far as house decorations, it seems much easier than last year’s craziness! It’s less than a week away and my own costume isn’t even done! I did test one new recipe on friends, which was a success, and I have deemed two other recipes as fine since I already prepped them since they will keep fine in the fridge, so that’s in good shape. Here is what I have been able to do so far:
My kingdom for a pipe wrench!
I had no idea it would be so difficult to find a pipe wrench that actually looks like the one in Clue! Since the game was created in 1949, and it was an antique wrench back then, no wonder! I have only found exact wrenches on eBay as antiques, requiring heavy shipping costs even if I won a low bid, and since I’m not sure I’ll ever have another Clue party in the future, I’m trying not to “invest” in props and decor as I do for Halloween or Mardi Gras. My grandmother had an antique pipe wrench I brought back from Christmas, but it’s not old enough, plus rather small to be believable as a murder weapon, so I’ve settled for a new version, large enough to be usable on my own house plumbing if necessary, and definitely large enough to inflict damage. Since it had a red handle but I want my weapons to look like oversized game pieces, I spray-painted it silver.
Other Weapons
I bought clean white rope and tied it into the same loop as the board game piece. The candlestick is ready to go of course. I bought a galvanized steel pipe instead of lead, since I wanted the silver game piece look. I have a choice of two revolvers, since my Wild West six-shooter from Bullets N BBQ has a different handle than my game piece, so I got a $1 pirate pistol that makes obnoxious electronic noises and spray-painted that silver. My Psycho-style butcher knife that is the traditional bleeding heart server each Halloween is my default knife, but it doesn’t match the game piece. I have a tiny knife in leather holster from my mom, but I think it’s a bit small to be a murder weapon, so I’m still looking for the perfect knife. I might cut down one of my $1 costume swords so it’ll have a cool handle & just not worry about a blade. Still working on that one…
The Game Board
The idea is to use my own house layout as the Boddy Mansion for the game board, using the costume winners as the playing pieces. Since we won’t be able to hear people yelling around the house, we might have the playing pieces running back & forth, or only going into place when they reach a room, then they will hold the weapon when the Suggestion is made. Before any game board sketching starts, I have been playing around with the floor plan of my house, laying out 1ft squares as the floor tiles for the game board motion between rooms. I have been seriously cleaning my office to use as the Library, only making good enough progress this past week, so I still have the game board to draw. For my original layout I would probably need 100 floor tiles, and I only bought 27 so far, and even at 3 for $1 at Dollar Tree, that is adding up quickly for a non-investment party, so I’m revising the pathways again before sketching. I’m not sure yet if I will use clear contact paper for the room name lettering and stick to the floor. I’m not sure if that will be as funny as I think. Since I already own the contact paper, it will be cheap & easy enough to try on Friday & see how it looks.
My own costume…
Even though I have the perfect Miss Scarlett dress, I plan to be Mrs. Peacock, since not only can I not resist the chance for an over-the-top teal costume creation, but I have 5 yards of turquoise crushed panne velvet I bought for my original Britta Skeeter idea and never used, so might as well finally use it. I have a basic sketch, but my teal satin bodice slightly clashes with the turquoise velvet, so I have handstitched to the teal bodice with matching sparkly spandex fabric so that it blends instead of making a dress with boning from scratch. I’ve bought feathers to add to the neckline, but haven’t figured out how to attach them best yet. An antique blue velvet hat I’ve never yet had the chance to wear has already been decorated with real peacock feathers and a tiny beaded fake bird peacock. I even have matching teal nail polish thanks to
I hope people can actually come, since I only have about 14 people confirmed so far. Everyone I talked to at Christmas seemed to like the idea, but we might be caught in spring schedule chaos, so we’ll see. As long as the people who do come are creative & have fun, then that’s what matters. 
Across the Clueniverse
Across the Clueniverse was a success with 20 people who had lots of fun! The whole point was for my guests to have a chance to be creative and have fun, and I was not disappointed! The costumes were all fabulous, everyone loved my themed food, we watched the Clue movie including all 3 possible endings, and we even played the game on my custom Brittahytta Mansion Special Edition board. I even got all the dishes done by 2am last night and the kitties let me sleep in all the way to 10:45am today, so I’m very glad after the 3 hours sleep Friday night & 5 hours Thursday night!
I had not assigned characters to people, so I was pleasantly surprised that with only 20 people we actually had at least one of every suspect! I was Mrs. Peacock, Galt was Professor Plum, Melanie was Mrs. White, Nat was Mr. Green, and Jack was Colonel Mustard. We only had one double, which was Miss Scarlet (Lyle) & Mr. Scarlet (Ben), so that voting was the only one that mattered for that category, and ended up as a “dead” tie anyway with 7 votes to each Scarlet. Most Original Costume was Robin as the Rope, only beating Chalk Mark Cyd by the final ballot. Other creative costumes were Charles as the Lead Pipe, Amy as a Red Herring, and Jeff J. as the Confidential Envelope where you put the whodunit cards for the Clue game. The nicely-vague Special Award went to Johnathon as Wadsworth the Butler complete with tux & tails, and Best Princess was Galen even though I kept trying to call her Miss Mustard in her yellow Belle dress. The prizes were bragging rights! I had never found silly little prizes that seemed appropriate and didn’t get any medals or certificates printed out. The favorite Suspect Shaken & Stirred cocktail was Black & Blue by Jeff J., but several recipes, including the Red Herring by Amy, were later recreated by other guests who wanted to taste them. I am so pleased everyone was being so creative with the drinks! We should have tried to take a group photo like for a game box cover but I didn’t even think of it, and too much was going on then people were removing costume pieces or already leaving anyway. At least we have everyone’s suspect photos in the gallery album!
Final Party Prep
I hadn’t planned on outrageous decorations for this party, but it did require all rooms being presentable & nice so I’ve been buying & building new furniture & redecorating my kitchen (separate posts to come), doing yardwork & serious spring cleaning, including my office as the Library, which was such a mess that was taking a lot of time. Because the office was still in such an awful state that I wasn’t sure it could actually be the Library, that means I hadn’t actually drawn the game board until Wednesday night! I had stitched fabric the week before to my bodice & my hat was done, but I hadn’t ever started on my skirts until the night before the party. Most last-minute major party prep ever I think, since usually things like decorations, voting ballots, menu signs are done ahead of time, then it’s just food that’s being done in the final crunch. I was still designing and printing the voting ballots & menu signs Saturday morning after finally finishing my costume at 4am. I didn’t even think of the mix your own cocktail idea for Suspects Shaken & Stirred until driving home Thursday night!
Friday I took off work as vacation, so the cookies were decorated & pastry brie was assembled Thursday & Friday, but it turned so windy that I decided against sweeping the patios until right before the party at 2pm after I did my makeup, otherwise I’d just do it again right before the party anyway. The monthly housecleaners came at 10am earlier than I thought so I was frantically putting kitchen stuff away as they were cleaning other rooms. They nicely vacuumed my screened patio for me, so that helped a lot! I did get my lawns mowed and the final grocery shopping done Friday too. Friday evening I started the rest of my costume which took several hours, then I hand-colored the game board & glued it to matting I had cut to size and scored to fold. I hadn’t traced the room floor signs onto clear contact paper until Friday afternoon, and just the outlines took almost 2 hours, so I never had time to fill them in, so they’re a bit hard to see on the floors. Those were finally stuck on the floor about 1pm Saturday along with the vinyl floor tiles marking the game board spaces. I never did put the Kitchen sign on the floor since it was getting so much heavy food prep foot traffic. My carpet was not being as cooperative with the contact paper as I’d like, so for a couple hours before the party I had boxes of crackers holding down the edges of the Billiard Room and piano books holding down the Ballroom which did help. A few signs came unstuck during the party, and my spike heels poked through the vinyl tiles that were on the carpet – oops! Glad they were only 3 tiles for $1 at Dollar Tree! By 3pm I was ready to start the fresh food prep…a little later than I’d like especially with no helpers, but not too bad considering everything else. At least I did already have 40s music playing on the stereo including the outside speakers, so we had nice vintage background music for our party soundtrack.
Party Details
Melanie arrived a little early to get in costume since she was borrowing one of my black wigs to be Madeline Kahn as Mrs. White, then Jeff J. was the first guest to arrive slightly before 4pm, so he was enlisted as my main fresh food helper. Great job Jeff! I had done my makeup a couple hours earlier, so I just needed to take out my curlers & put on my outfit, which I did right at 4pm and only took 5 minutes since I made it between timer beeps checking the pastry brie in the oven. Galt & Lyle as Professor Plum & Miss Scarlet were next to arrive, so with their help putting the extra fruit & veggies away, all the food was set by the next guests to arrive, probably no later than 5 but I wasn’t checking time. The last thing was the chicken since it was baked & cooled before it could go out. My test batch of the chicken skewers had gotten a little overcooked, so I was extra careful in underbaking them Friday night. By heating them for the party they were nice & moist, but I let them cool before putting them on the plastic aqua serving tray, arranged in a peacock tail fan of course. I had Party Swirls thawed and cheese ready to slice, but since I was only expecting about 20 people maximum it looked like we had plenty of food already with just the themed food so since more people were arriving I stopped kitchen work and started socializing. I created a menu board on parchment in a silver frame so I could be witty with the descriptions (full menu sign here). I had decided a couple phrases on the recipes I had to develop from scratch, but some weren’t done until the morning of the party when I designed & printed the menu sign! I even had fresh flowers from my yard around the house, and 3 dishes of Red Herrings were in various locations too. Since there were other people still on their way who were coming in costume, the majority decided to watch the Clue movie around 6:30. My outside speaker setup allowed people to get drinks & still keep up with the movie, and others who weren’t watching a different place to chat while still hearing what was going on in the movie. Matt made an appearance even after his 100 mile bike ride – impressive! Jeff O. & Audene came later as Innocent Bystanders but they left before the voting so I forgot to get a photo of them…darn! There were some veggies left, enough brie for me to taste a couple bites, some crackers, 3 of the 52 chicken skewers and a few of the 4 dozen cookies, but otherwise the food was pretty much gone so that worked out well.
Whodunit?
Several people decided to leave around 9ish after I announced the winners, but those who remained played a game of Clue using my custom game board. The cards were checked that all were still there, then Ben’s friend Brian shuffled them, others selected the cards and Jeff put them into his oversize confidential envelope costume.They decided not to actually walk the house while playing (waah!), but when it was Suggested that Mrs Peacock did it in the Lounge with the Revolver and we were in the Lounge already and a revolver prop was sitting right there, I made them take a photo of me posing, shooting at the Lounge sign. hehe… When more were being Suggested in the Lounge, we placed the playing pieces in the correct seats on the board, so I took a photo of course. heehee. Finally there was a big reveal of clues that led to a false Accusation, so Jen was out of the game. Then Brian made the winning Accusation…Who would ever expect that your hostess was the murderer?!? Seriously, we did not plan this, it was as random as any other game of Clue, but Mrs Peacock did it in the Hall with the Wrench!
Only a Suggestion: Mrs. Peacock in the Lounge with the Revolver – who can disprove?
The rest of the guests left after the game was over after 10pm, except for Jeff J. & Amy who stayed after everyone else for a nice catchup chat until they left a little after 11pm. I was still awake enough for cleanup, but not for wee hours party blogging! A few catchup photos today, then I had a leisurely afternoon touching up photos, uploading, and writing this post until I left for dinner before Ragtime, which was excellent. Juanita (
I hope everyone had a nice weekend!
Subscribe RSS
